We'll always have a soft spot for that first Johnnie-O polo, but we've made a few thoughtful updates over the years. The Thatcher keeps the cut of our Original Polo with a two-button collar and a pocketless chest for a sleeker look. We also added some tencel to the fabric makeup, aka, the stuff that'll have you saying it's the softest polo you've ever owned. . johnnie-O Slub Cotton Blend Polo Shirt - Thatcher Stripe in Blue Size: XL.